Friday, August 5, 2016

The open letter of former cabinet officers, senior officials and career military officers who denounced Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump

For over six decades, maintaining a strong NATO Alliance has been one of the most important strategic objectives of the United States. Every American President since Harry Truman, Republican and Democrat, has believed that defending our alliance of democracies is a vital U.S. interest, especially the core commitment enshrined in Article 5 of the NATO treaty -- that an attack on one of us is an attack on all of us.

Donald Trump’s recent statements casting doubt on whether he would honor that commitment should one of our allies be attacked compels us to respond. Just last week, Trump said he would consider recognizing the Russian annexation of Crimea and lifting sanctions on Moscow. He also encouraged the Russian government to hack into Secretary Clinton's emails. These are disgraceful statements that betray our longstanding values and national interests embraced by Presidents of both parties.


All of us have served our government as cabinet officers, senior officials, and career military officers. We find Trump’s comments to be reckless, dangerous, and extremely unwise. They contradict a core, bipartisan principle found in every U.S. Administration - - that our security in North America is indivisible with our democratic allies in Europe.

Trump’s ill-considered statements have already sown doubt in the minds of our European partners as to whether they can count on American resolve, commitment, and strength in the future. Those statements also threaten to weaken our collective deterrence against Vladimir Putin from further territorial aggression in Europe after his invasions of Ukraine and Georgia. If Trump’s policy was implemented, it would undermine the essential credibility of the United States in Europe and around the world.

NATO and our other alliances strengthen, not weaken us. They are our greatest strategic advantage over countries like Russia that have no allies. They help the American people to shoulder the military and financial burden as we seek to maintain the peace around the world. To treat our alliances as base transactions, as Trump appears to do in his consistent criticism of our allies, is to misunderstand their essential importance to our own security.


Hours after the catastrophic 9/11 attacks against our country, Canada and our European allies invoked Article 5 for the first time in NATO’s history and pledged to defend the United States in our time of need. All of our allies then joined us in our fight in Afghanistan against Al Qaeda and the Taliban. Many of them still fight with us today. A solemn obligation of the American President is to lead NATO, to remain resolute in defense of our allies and to convince potential adversaries that we will stand up for NATO without fear or reservation. Every President, without exception, has accepted the wisdom of this strategy. That is why we find Trump’s cavalier denigration of NATO so worrying and so objectionable. Strong alliances are essential to U.S. national security. America needs a President who will strengthen our alliances not denigrate and destroy them.

Signed,

Madeleine Albright Former Secretary of State

General John R. Allen, USMC (Ret.) Former Commander of NATO International Security Assistance Force and U.S. Forces Afghanistan

 Jeremy Bash Former Chief of Staff at the Department of Defense and CIA

John B. Bellinger III Former Legal Advisor to the Department of State and Former Legal Advisor to the National Security Council

 John Beyrle Former U.S. Ambassador to Russia and to Bulgaria

Ian Brzezinski Former Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for European and NATO Policy

Nicholas Burns Former Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs and Former Ambassador to NATO

William J. Burns Former Deputy Secretary of State and Former Ambassador to Russia

Derek Chollet Former Assistant Secretary of Defense for International Security Affairs

 Lt. General Dan Christman, U.S. Army (Ret.) Former U.S. Representative to the NATO Military Committee and Former Superintendent of the United States Military Academy

General Wesley K. Clark, U.S. Army (Ret.) Supreme Allied Commander at NATO, 1997-2000

 Richard Danzig Secretary of the Navy, 1998-2001

Evelyn Farkas Former Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Russia, Ukraine and Eurasia

 Lee Feinstein Former U.S. Ambassador to Poland

Michele Flournoy Former Under Secretary of Defense for Policy, 2009-2012

Lt. Gen. Walter E. Gaskin, USMC (Ret.) Former Chairman and Deputy Chairman of Military Committee NATO

Philip Gordon Former Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs and Former White House Coordinator for the Middle East

 Marc Grossman Former Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs and Former Ambassador to Turkey

John Herbst Former U.S. Ambassador to Ukraine and to Uzbekistan

 Kathleen Hicks Former Principal Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Policy

Christopher Hill Former U.S. Ambassador to Poland, Iraq and South Korea

Beth Jones Former Assistant Secretary of State for Europe and Eurasia

 James N. Miller Former Under Secretary of Defense for Policy, 2012-2014

Leon E. Panetta Former Secretary of Defense and Director of the CIA

Thomas R. Pickering Former Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs and Former Ambassador to Russia

Steven Pifer Former U.S. Ambassador to Ukraine

Marcie Ries Former U.S. Ambassador to Bulgaria and to Albania

 Kori Schake Former Director for Defense Strategy and Requirements National Security Council

Randy Scheunemann Former Defense Department Consultant

Wendy R. Sherman Former Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs

Julianne Smith Former Deputy National Security Advisor to Vice President Joseph Biden

Admiral James Stavridis, USN (Ret.) Supreme Allied Commander at NATO, 2009-2013

James Steinberg Former Deputy Secretary of State

 Andrew Weiss Former Director for Russia, Ukraine, and Eurasia National Security Council

Damon Wilson Former Special Assistant to the President and Senior Director for European Affairs National Security Council

 Christine Wormuth Former Undersecretary of Defense for Policy, 2014-2016

Kenneth Yalowitz Former U.S. Ambassador to Georgia and to Belarus

No comments:

Post a Comment